Owner chat recording: task v12 worker evidence

Task: 39b11a5a-d63b-46c0-9c32-c799c6a948e0, exact frozen version 12. Execution: 6f616720-e7bc-481b-ac3e-b66eec23647f. Repository: h8v6/heyaira; branch: heyaira/39b11a5a. Source and starting HEAD: dd001791c264f6fc5bb91c30caa172506cf32924. Initial worktree: clean. No carried candidate was supplied in this checkout. The previous session's commit was unavailable in this Git object store, so the implementation and tests were recreated from the prior work without resetting, amending, rebasing or merging any commit. The prior blocker was execution lease expiry; the new task was explicitly assigned and read with task_get version 12. Subagents: none. Independent acceptance remains with the Bridge verifier.

Cause, change and confidence

The base has no MCP tool for an explicit owner chat answer and no owner_chat/said_at event support. The new tool is an interactive owner/admin session attestation for consent/rule, with explicit flags/prefixes retaining the payment/secret/deletion key boundary. It reuses unchanged proposal validation and appends the answer in one transaction, either with a new proposal or to an existing proposed decision. The operation does not call notification enqueueing. It preserves the existing task/key/idempotency lock order, with replay before time/state validation.

Migration 060 extends only the answer actor allowance and adds the required said_at and owner_chat constraints. Existing hashes, option checks, owner_key, delegate and immutable-event rules remain. Read projections expose server-derived attribution, quote and answer time. The test harness opts decision suites into ASGI while unrelated execution tests keep their original TCP default. Confidence is high from real MCP/HTTP, PostgreSQL, negative-write count assertions and notification positive controls; no live device, deployment or acceptance is claimed.

Execution environment

All commands ran in /Users/jablonskib/HeyAira-agents/.heyaira-worktrees/heyaira/39b11a5a-worker. The HEAD at test time was the source SHA; implementation/test changes were in the working tree. The resulting SHA is recorded in RESULT/receipt after committing. The commands below ran with TMPDIR="$PWD/.work-tmp". The prepared local PostgreSQL was reached by Unix socket. The runner created and dropped disposable databases only. No installation, credential or DSN is included. Git commands used DEVELOPER_DIR=/Library/Developer/CommandLineTools; cache/global ignore permission warnings did not prevent the observed successful operations.

Commands and actual results

Base regression ran before implementation or migration changes, with only the new tests and their ASGI harness added:

python scripts/test_postgres.py tests/test_owner_chat.py::test_k1_admin_consent_roundtrip_and_single_use tests/test_owner_chat.py::test_k7_valid_owner_chat_insert -p no:cacheprovider
exit: 1
2 failed in 4.92s
K1: Unknown tool: decision_record_owner_answer
K7: asyncpg.exceptions.UndefinedColumnError: column "said_at" of relation "decision_events" does not exist

The same regression tests passed within both runs below.

python scripts/test_postgres.py tests/test_owner_chat.py -p no:cacheprovider
exit: 0
41 passed in 22.31s
postgres_acceptance=passed: selected tests, zero skipped tests

python scripts/test_postgres.py tests/test_owner_chat.py tests/test_decisions*.py tests/test_schema_guard.py tests/test_mcp_runtime_contract.py -p no:cacheprovider
exit: 0
172 passed in 97.73s (0:01:37)
postgres_acceptance=passed: selected tests, zero skipped tests

PYTHONPATH=src python scripts/export_mcp_contract.py --check
exit: 0; MCP contract is up to date

PYTHONPATH=src python scripts/check_docs_contract.py
exit: 0; documentation contract passed: 48 MCP tools covered

git diff --check
exit: 0; no whitespace errors

git merge-base --is-ancestor dd00179 HEAD
exit: 0

Frozen criteria

K1

Mode 1: admin interactive token records a consent (authorizes=true, owner_list all false) -> decision_list(state=all) shows in_force, confirmed_by=owner_chat, attested_by, quote, session_label, said_at; decision_check(use=true) succeeds once. Fails on dd00179.

Frozen method: python scripts/test_postgres.py <new tests> -p no:cacheprovider; RESULT states base outcome.

criterion_id: K1
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: Targeted command exit 0; admin consent list/continuity attribution, quote/session/said_at round-trip and single consumption passed. Base K1 regression exit 1: Unknown tool.

K2

Mode 2: an existing proposed decision answered via decision_id -> in_force without duplicate or conflict; mode 1 with a pending same-key proposal -> decision_record_pending_exists. authorizes=false option -> rejected. Rule: decision_check use=false ok, use=true -> decision_use_not_applicable.

Frozen method: Targeted tests via scripts/test_postgres.py -> passed.

criterion_id: K2
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: Targeted command exit 0; existing proposed ID answered with the original content hash, no duplicate/conflict, pending-key refusal, rejection and rule use semantics passed.

K3

Key boundary and type: paid/secret/deletion flags or cost-/secret-/delete- prefixes -> decision_requires_owner_key; misleading generic key + paid=true refused; migration=true allowed; staffing -> decision_record_type_not_allowed; approval param -> decision_record_approval_not_allowed; past valid_until -> decision_record_expired; nothing written on refusal.

Frozen method: Targeted tests -> passed.

criterion_id: K3
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: Targeted command exit 0; paid/secret/deletion flags and all reserved prefixes refused in both modes without writes; migration allowed; staffing, approval and past valid_until refused.

K4

Authorization order: execution credential -> decision_record_requires_interactive_session; contributor and viewer -> project_admin_required; no grant-family principal -> principal_unavailable; nothing written.

Frozen method: Targeted tests -> passed.

criterion_id: K4
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: Targeted command exit 0; execution before scope, contributor/viewer before scope, missing grant-family principal and OAuth write scope tested with unchanged decision/event counts.

K5

No decision_waiting event and no push delivery row after recording (counts before/after).

Frozen method: Targeted test -> passed.

criterion_id: K5
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: Targeted command exit 0; waiting-event and delivery counts unchanged in both modes; a normal proposal increases both counts with an active Mac and phone.

K6

Idempotency: replay before age validation (identical retry after the 7-day window returns the same result), concurrent identical calls -> one record, same key other principal -> idempotency_conflict.

Frozen method: Targeted tests -> passed.

criterion_id: K6
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: Targeted command exit 0; replay after eight-day clock advance, concurrent identical calls producing one decision/event, changed input and other-principal conflicts passed.

K7

Migration 060: a valid owner_chat INSERT succeeds (fails on dd00179); refusals for missing note, authenticator present, missing said_at, content_hash mismatch; owner_key/delegate rules and event immutability unchanged.

Frozen method: Targeted migration tests -> passed.

criterion_id: K7
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: Targeted command exit 0; valid direct INSERT and every specified refusal passed; old owner_key/delegate rules and event immutability retained. Base valid INSERT exit 1: missing said_at column.

K8

New tests, existing decision suites, schema guard and MCP contract pass with zero skips.

Frozen method: python scripts/test_postgres.py <new tests> tests/test_decisions*.py tests/test_schema_guard.py tests/test_mcp_runtime_contract.py -p no:cacheprovider -> exit 0.

criterion_id: K8
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: Frozen full command exit 0; 172 passed in 97.73s, zero skips.

K9

Scope: only src/heyaira/, tests/, docs/, contracts/mcp-tools.json, migrations/060_decision_owner_chat.sql since dd00179.

Frozen method: git diff --name-only dd00179..HEAD; git merge-base --is-ancestor dd00179 HEAD.

criterion_id: K9
outcome: pass
evidence_path: docs/reports/39b11a5a-owner-chat-evidence.md
feedback: git diff --name-only dd00179..HEAD and git merge-base --is-ancestor dd00179 HEAD both exited 0 at implementation commit 02bcf736f1418de373174cc4e83d680a9148aa11; all 15 paths are within scope. Final SHA, parent and clean status are in RESULT/receipt.

Scope and remaining work

Implementation files: src/heyaira/decision_owner_chat.py, decisions.py and server.py; migrations/060_decision_owner_chat.sql; contracts/mcp-tools.json. Targeted regressions: tests/test_owner_chat.py. Harness adaptations: tests/conftest.py, test_execution_e2e.py, test_workflow_e2e.py and the existing test_decisions suites. Documentation: docs/reference/mcp-tools.md, docs/concepts/decisions-how-it-works.md and this evidence file. All changes are within frozen K9 scope.

All mandatory runtime checks ran, with no skips. No push, PR, merge, installation, deploy or production operation was performed. RESULT/receipt submission and post-commit scope/status confirmation follow this evidence commit. Independent verification and publication are Bridge steps.

Post-commit confirmation

Implementation commit: 02bcf736f1418de373174cc4e83d680a9148aa11. Its parent is dd001791c264f6fc5bb91c30caa172506cf32924. git diff --name-only dd00179..HEAD exited 0 and listed 15 authorized paths: the implementation, migration, contract, tests and documentation described above. git merge-base --is-ancestor dd00179 HEAD exited 0. The evidence generation introduced one trailing blank line. The committed-diff whitespace check (git diff dd00179..HEAD --check, exit 2) reported that line; git diff --cached dd00179 --check then exited 0 with no whitespace errors. This documentation-only follow-up removes it and preserves the implementation commit. No runtime files changed after testing. Final whitespace, ancestry, scope and status results are retained in RESULT/receipt.